Umbrella Company vs PAYE: What should you choose?

How to choose between PAYE and Umbrella

What is an umbrella company?

Before we compare PAYE vs umbrella, let us first look at each option in more detail and what each entails.

An umbrella company employs a contractor and therefore takes certain tasks off their hands such as invoicing the client, chasing payments, paying them a salary and working out and deducting the correct level of tax and National Insurance through the PAYE system.

The PAYE system simply refers to pay-as-you-earn which is the most common form of taxation in the UK and is paid by most UK employees.

Under the PAYE tax system, the current tax bands are as follows:

  • Personal allowance (tax-free) – Up to £12,500 a year
  • Basic rate (20%) – £12,501 to £50,000 a year
  • Higher rate (40%) – £50,001 to £150,000 a year
  • Additional rate (45%) – More than £150,000 a year

If you live in Scotland, the income tax rates are slightly different as follows:

  • Personal allowance (tax-free)– Up to £12,500 a year
  • Starter rate (19%) – £12,501 to £514,585 a year
  • Basic rate (20%) – £14,586 to £25,158 a year
  • Intermediate rate (21%) –£25,159 to £43,430 a year
  • Higher rate (41%) – £43,431 to £150,000 a year
  • Top rate (46%) – more than £150,000 a year

The PAYE system in Wales is based on the following tax bands:

  • Tax-freePersonal allowance: up to £12,500 per year
  • Basic rate (20%):£12,501 – £50,000 per year
  • Higher rate (40%):£50,001 – £150,000 per year
  • Additional rate (45%):over £150,000 per year

As the company’s employee, umbrella company contractors also qualify for statutory rights such as sick pay, paid holiday leave, a workplace pension and maternity or paternity leave.

Find out more about umbrella sick pay and other statutory rights in our handy guide.

Contractors can still choose which contracts they work on and when, but they don’t have to deal with the tasks and finances of running their own business like self-employed contractors do through a limited company.

What is a PAYE agency?

A PAYE agency also employs the contractor, however they dictate which contracts the contractor must work on and when.

Under a PAYE agency, just like with an umbrella company, the contractor will also be paid a salary and have their tax deducted and paid according to PAYE tax bands. They will similarly qualify for statutory benefits and have general admin tasks taken care of for them.

So what is the difference between PAYE and umbrella?

The main differences between PAYE and umbrella include:

Who chooses your contracts

One significant difference between the two options is who chooses which contracts the contractor will work on and when.

Whereas with an umbrella company the contractor is free to source and select which contracts they work on and with which clients, a PAYE agency will make this decision for the contractor.

For this reason, contractors that wish to be in charge of their own career development and progression usually opt for the umbrella route.

Continuity of employment 

With a PAYE agency every new contract the contractor takes on is a separate run of employment. On the other hand, with an umbrella company your employment will continue from contract to contract, meaning one handy tax code.

This makes life easier when doing things like applying for a mortgage or loan.


Another difference between PAYE and umbrella is whether you can claim tax relief on work-related expenses.

The good news is that most umbrella companies will allow contractors to claim for expenses which can reduce the amount of tax you need to pay. However, PAYE agencies don’t usually offer this option.

There is also a third option – limited company. To find out more about umbrella vs limited company and the pros and cons of each route check out our guide.

Which route is best for me?

Having looked at the key differences between PAYE vs umbrella, it’s time to make a decision about which route is best for you.

It is worth noting that both the PAYE and umbrella options process tax through PAYE, however, umbrella companies do allow contractors to claim business expenses which can reduce the amount of tax paid.

Contractors should also look at the degree of freedom and flexibility they want over their careers.

If the ability to choose which contracts you work on and which clients you work with is important to you, umbrella is the best way to go. After all, with an umbrella company contractors are free to progress their careers and move forward at a pace that’s right for them, unlike with a PAYE agency which dictates which contracts you will work on.

Thousands of contractors select the umbrella company route as a way to combine the security and stability of employment with the benefits of being self-employed and being able to choose which contracts you work on.

If you’ve weighed up your options and decided that umbrella company is the way to go, Umbrella Supermarket is here to help you find the best umbrella company for you.

Ready to find the best umbrella company?

Our handy umbrella calculator makes it quick and easy for contractors to find the best umbrella company for their needs and requirements.

After all, there are hundreds of umbrella companies out there competing for your custom which can make it confusing to know which company is the best to work with.

That’s where our contractor calculator comes into play. By simply entering a few details about yourself, such as your contractor rate and requirements, our umbrella calculator will generate a list of the best umbrella companies for you.

Why not see what our umbrella calculator can do for you today?

Would you like more information on Umbrella Company vs PAYE: What should you choose??

Explore More Resources

Using an Umbrella Calculator

The Pros of Using an Umbrella Calculator

There are many advantages to using an umbrella calculator for contractors.

Umbrella calculators allow you to quickly compare thousands of umbrella companies across the UK, offering a clear overview of what you will receive from the company, including everything from your take-home pay, what benefits you will receive, and what services the company will offer.

To help contractors find out more, Umbrella Supermarket outlines the main benefits to using an umbrella calculator in 2021.

umbrella vs limited

Umbrella vs Limited Company: What to know when making the move this new tax year

The 6th April 2021 marked significant changes to IR35 legislation which impacted thousands of self-employed, limited company contractors operating within the private sector.

In light of the changes that have now rolled out, many limited company contractors are understandably considering their options and thinking about making the move to umbrella this new tax year.

To help make the decision that little bit easier, in this guide Umbrella Supermarket outline what contractors need to know about making the move from limited company to umbrella in 2021, to help you get on the right track.


avoid ir35

How can I avoid IR35?

As a contractor, you will most likely know about IR35 and upcoming reforms from April 2021.

These changes to IR35 legislation are set to badly impact many self-employed contractors in the private sector, so thousands are understandably worried. After all, getting caught out by IR35 can mean you end up paying more in tax than you need at the same level as an employee, without receiving the benefits of being employed, such as statutory rights.

umbrella company costs

Umbrella Company Fees: How Much Should You Pay?

When deciding which umbrella company to work with, the fees they charge will inevitably play an important role in the decision-making process.

Umbrella company fees are taken directly out of the contractor’s income, so it is only natural that contractors want to ensure they are getting a fair deal.

To help contractors understand umbrella company fees, from how they are charged, what they will receive in return, and how much they should be paying, Umbrella Supermarket outlines everything there is to know about umbrella fees in this handy guide.

umbrella vs limited

Pros and Cons of Limited vs. Umbrella

Big reforms to IR35 legislation are set to come into motion from 6th April 2021 which will impact the thousands of self-employed, private-sector contractors out there.

For this reason, many of the contractors that currently operate through a limited company will be considering the umbrella company route as an alternative.

If this is true for you, it’s important to do your research to find out whether limited company vs umbrella is the best option for you in 2021.

To help make the decision that little bit easier, in this guide Umbrella Supermarket outline the key differences between limited vs umbrella, so you can get on the right track.

2021 budget

What Does the 2021 Budget Mean for Contractors?

On 3rd March 2021 Chancellor Rishi Sunak unveiled his Budget in the House of Commons, outlining the government’s tax and spending plans for the year ahead.

Sunak announced a variety of measures he will put into place to help businesses and jobs that have suffered through the pandemic, as well as outlining a plan for the long-term recovery of the economy.

However, the question many contractors will be asking is how the Budget will impact the

umbrella company

5 Benefits to Working with an Umbrella Company

Contracting through an umbrella company has become an increasingly popular option for contractors across the UK in recent years. After all, it is a route that offers contractors a range of benefits over other paths such as working through PAYE or being self-employed.



ir35 reforms

Contractor’s Guide to IR35 in 2021

From April 6th 2021, reforms to IR35 legislation will come into force, impacting the lives of thousands of self-employed contractors.

Inevitably, contractors across the UK are concerned about upcoming reforms and how these will affect them. To help, in this guide, Umbrella Supermarket look at what these changes to IR35 entail and how they might impact you as a contractor in 2021.


compare umbrella company fees

How to Compare Umbrella Company Fees

If you are considering joining an umbrella company in 2021, or have been contracting through one for a while and want to ensure you are getting a good deal, it is important that you know how to compare umbrella company fees.

What you pay in income tax and National Insurance will be the same regardless of which umbrella company you choose, however the fees the umbrella company charges can make a big difference to your take home pay.

At Umbrella Supermarket, we know that every contractor wants to get a fair deal. To help, we explain how umbrella company fees work and how you can compare them to find the best deal.

job retention scheme

Job Retention Scheme for Contractors in 2021

The COVID-19 pandemic has impacted workers across the UK and contractors have been no exception.

Many of the 1.77 million independent contractors have either lost work altogether or have had contracts put temporarily on hold leaving them in a tricky position.

Fortunately, many of these contractors are eligible for the government’s Job Retention Scheme otherwise known as furlough, introduced to offer financial support for businesses and workers. This has been an essential source of income for many who have lost contract work as a result of the pandemic.

As we experience a third national lockdown, the furlough scheme has now been extended until the 30th April. So, if you find yourself out of contract work or have projects on hold, Umbrella Supermarket are here to explain what the Job Retention Scheme is, how it works and what this means for contractors.