What’s the difference between an Umbrella Company and standard PAYE?
Contractors using an Umbrella Company’s PAYE payroll will encounter additional deductions from their gross pay in the form of fees and Employers National Insurance contributions when compared to a normal employee.
Employers National Insurance (ENI) contributions are additional National Insurance payments that an employer has to make over and above the contributions an employee makes from their salary. As part of the Umbrella Contractor relationship, in return for a low Umbrella Company processing fee, the cost of ENI is deducted from the gross billed amount on a contract.
Through standard PAYE, there’s no Umbrella processing fee, and the burden of ENI falls on the employer meaning that the full salary is goes through the company payroll.
It’s important to remember that contractors are often paid a higher day rate than a normal employee for the same work to compensate for this.
Additionally, there are other reasons why a contractor’s day rate might be inflated over and above an equivalent employee’s including:
- The loss of holiday pay
- The loss of sick pay
- To cover basic equipment costs
- Down time between contracts
If a contractor were to be paid the same per day as an employee they would be at a significant financial disadvantage.
Firstly, this is because a salaried worker on £52,200 per annum is effectively paid £200 for every possible working day of the year (in 2019 that will be 261 days).
An equivalent contractor will not be able to bill 261 days a year, as they will need to take time off on holiday. This means that assuming on average contractors take 25 days holiday a year, they will need to earn £221 per day to make £52,200 per year.
Secondly,the impact of holidays on billable days is not actually the biggest hit a contractor will take. If a contractor were to earn £52,200 per year, they would actually pay £5,972.64 more in tax than an employee because they have to pay the full Employers National Insurance contributions from their day rate. That’s an effective hit of £25 per working day.
Thirdly, in addition to the ENI and billableday’s implications of being a contractor, the fee charged by an Umbrella Company comes off the £52,200. On average working through an Umbrella Company will cost £4 per working day meaning that a contractor will actually take home £51,256 (£196) before even considering points one and two.
For a contractor on £52,200, the relative hit when these three problems are combined is £50 per day, meaning to move from standard PAYE to Umbrella PAYE, a £52,200 contractor needs to be earning 25% more than a normal employee to see any financial benefit.